AI Isn't Failing You. It's Having an Off Moment
What You Do Next Is the Whole Game
The mood around AI has turned. After two years of breathless promises (and don’t get me wrong, transformational benefit) a lot of capable people are quietly disappointed. The outputs are uneven. The tool that dazzled on Monday turns in something mediocre on Thursday. My clients are sharing stories of content-avalanches and data fabrication - the question underneath it is whether the whole thing was oversold.
I want to offer a different read — and it comes from a different place than most AI commentary. I've spent my career coaching leaders through exactly this kind of change, not configuring software.
AI is not unreliable. It's inconsistent. Those aren't the same thing, and the gap between them is exactly where leadership lives.
An unreliable tool fails predictably, so you stop using it. An inconsistent one moves in and out of precision — sharp, then flat, then sharp again — in a way that feels a lot like working with a talented person having an uneven week. And here's what I've watched happen: the professionals getting real value from AI aren't the ones with the cleverest prompts. They're the ones who already know how to work with a capable colleague who's off their game — because they've been doing it with people for years.
They don't end the relationship at the first bad output. They get curious about what changed. They adjust their own input before they blame the instrument. They stay.
That's not a technical skill. It's a relational one — the same patience good managers have always brought to the humans in front of them.
There's a line I keep returning to with the leaders I coach:
The response to an off moment determines the trajectory more than the off moment itself
It's true of a direct report who hands in weak work. It turns out to be just as true of the tool on your desk.
So if AI has been letting you down lately, the honest question isn't only whether the technology is good enough yet. It's also: what are you doing in the moment it falls short? One of those you can't control. The other is entirely yours.
The tools will keep having off days. Whether that derails you was never really about the tools.
If the way your team works with AI is the real question underneath all this, that's the work I do.
More from Make Work Better: We’re not ready for the year ahead